Evaluating Perennials for Chicagoland Gardens

Perennials in Focus is a plant evaluation program that examines new and underused plants for Chicagoland, the third largest metropolitan area in the country. A group of horticultural experts trials and evaluates plants at numerous locations across the region. Results help consumers, public gardens, growers, landscape designers, breeders, and other industry professionals make informed plant choices.

perennialsinfocus@perennialsinfocus.com

Comparing Pollinator Visits to Rudbeckia hirta and Ratibida pinnata

Comparing insect visitation diversity on Rudbeckia hirta and Ratibida pinnata is more useful than asking which flower has “more insects.” Because their floral structures and rewards differ, a sound comparison must record how many kinds of insects arrive, how evenly they are represented and whether they transfer pollen. Hoverflies, native solitary bees, butterflies and beetles may visit the same plant while contributing different pollination services.

Perennials in Focus offers a regional lens: its collaborative Chicagoland trials record bloom period, flower colour, height and spread across multiple gardens and seasons. Those findings reflect a particular climate, however, and are not automatic ratings for Australian conditions. This comparison translates them into an Australian framework, combining field-observation methods with the way these plants are grown and sold in Melbourne, Sydney, Adelaide and Brisbane.

Character Rudbeckia hirta Ratibida pinnata
Flower architecture Broad yellow rays surrounding a dark brown to black centre Several drooping yellow rays surrounding an elongated grey-brown cone
Typical stature 30–90 cm tall and 30–60 cm wide 60–150 cm tall and roughly 30–90 cm wide
Likely visitation emphasis Broad access and a conspicuous landing surface for bees, butterflies and flies Nectar-focused visits by bees and butterflies around an elevated cone
Useful garden contribution A colourful, low display that is easy to inspect Height, prairie character and a different floral profile
Australian consideration Often grown as an annual; reliable once established in sunny, well-drained soil Usually steadier in richer soil; may need dependable moisture and support

Measuring insect visitation diversity

Visitor richness is the number of insect species or reliably distinguishable groups recorded; evenness describes how evenly visits are shared. Total abundance answers a different question. Ten hoverflies can create a busy scene without matching the variety of five bees, two butterflies, a fly and a beetle. Both diversity and abundance should be recorded, and an unusual sighting should not become a broad conclusion.

That emphasis on regional relevance is central to the regional trial mission: Perennials in Focus tests plants across multiple Chicagoland sites so findings reflect garden conditions rather than one exceptional specimen. Flowering records can establish observation windows, but an insect count still needs a fixed interval, a calm-weather rule and a repeatable identification method.

Use equal periods, such as 20 minutes per flowering plant, and repeat them in morning and afternoon on several dry days. Note wind, temperature, cloud cover and nearby bloom. Ideally, the same observer watches marked plants, records every insect contacting the flower head and identifies it to the lowest reliable level.

Rudbeckia hirta as an insect landing platform

Rudbeckia hirta forms a compact, often short-lived perennial or annual with broad yellow rays around a conspicuous dark disc. The open face provides a landing and feeding platform for bees, butterflies and hoverflies, while exposed florets offer nectar and pollen. Its lower stature also makes the flower easy to inspect in a busy public or home garden.

The programme's notes on beneficial insects from Chicago vegetable gardens show why flowering plants should be considered within a broader insect community. For R. hirta, count insects actually contacting the flower head and log movement between plants separately. Adults resting on leaves and predators hunting nearby are useful observations, but not evidence of pollination.

Australian garden centres commonly recognise the plant as black-eyed Susan and offer it in seed, plug and flowering-pot ranges. Gardeners in frost-prone districts usually treat it as an annual, while those in mild, sheltered sites may see it return for several seasons. Check the botanical label because common names are used loosely in the local market.

Ratibida pinnata and the prairie nectar cone

Ratibida pinnata has a tall stem, a long grey-brown central cone and several downward-curving yellow rays. The elevated, nectar-rich cone suits bees and butterflies, although its limited ray surface offers less of a landing platform than R. hirta. The open flower head also remains visible above many companion plants, making it conspicuous in a mixed border.

This architecture may produce a different, rather than simply larger, visitor list. Bees can work the cone closely, butterflies approach from above, and hoverflies move between heads. Small wasps and beetles may also appear, so identification matters. Record whether an insect landed, fed or merely passed the stem; sustained contact with florets is more relevant to pollination.

Australian growers value the species for prairie-style borders and sunny pollinator beds, although it is less familiar in mainstream retail than black-eyed Susan. It generally performs best in full sun with dependable moisture while its roots establish. Exposed Melbourne and Adelaide beds may need staking, while humid Sydney and Brisbane gardens require excellent drainage.

Translating Chicago seasons to Australia

Season is the largest obstacle to transferring Chicago findings directly. Chicagoland's main display runs from early summer into early autumn, while these plants can flower from late spring through summer across much of southern Australia. Mild, wet-winter Melbourne, dry-summer Adelaide, humid Sydney and subtropical Brisbane all shift plant growth and insect activity differently, so local bloom records should determine when counts begin.

Water and heat change floral rewards as well as stature. Established R. hirta usually handles dry, reflective garden surfaces better, whereas R. pinnata can appreciate deeper soil and regular moisture. Mulch, drip irrigation and afternoon shade can extend flowering in hotter cities, but overwatering encourages weak growth. Record interventions because stressed plants may offer fewer viable florets.

Australian planting customs often favour seasonal displays, compact plots and water-wise choices, all of which alter the surrounding insect habitat. Many Australian native bees are solitary, so a steady nectar sequence can be especially valuable. Both plants are introduced North American species, so neither should replace native wildflowers. Pair them with region-appropriate daisies and wattles, and check council weed lists before allowing seed to spread.

Building a repeatable field comparison

A simple protocol makes the comparison repeatable. On each flowering day, choose matched plants receiving similar light and soil conditions. Watch for the same length of time, photograph the bed, record the hour and weather, and list each insect group with its visit type. Repeat on at least six dates across early, middle and late flowering rather than generalising from one sunny afternoon.

Digital records can help, but resized images or mismatched display settings can distort comparisons. Before scoring or sharing photographs, consult a screen resolution guide, then compare images at the same scale on the same or calibrated screen. Keep a field notebook as the primary record, with photographs supporting identification rather than replacing observed behaviour.

Analyse richness, evenness and total visits separately, then relate them to weather, bloom age and plant size. If R. hirta attracts more fly and beetle records while R. pinnata records a broader bee range, growing both may be the best response. Complementarity, flowering continuity and reliable identification are more valuable than declaring a universal winner from one site.

Growing a pollinator-friendly patch

Choose according to the role required. For a low sunny edge, close-range viewing or a broad landing surface for butterflies, R. hirta is the practical option. For the middle or back of a large border, a prairie look or abundant elevated nectar, R. pinnata adds vertical structure. Confirm mature size before ordering, and avoid confusion with other Ratibida species sold as prairie coneflower or Mexican hat.

Buy healthy, correctly named plants from Australian nurseries, and avoid unnecessary seed near sensitive bushland. Remove escaped seedlings, dispose of spent heads responsibly and follow local council guidance on introduced species. Plant one specimen of each in comparable sunny positions, begin ten-minute insect observations before peak flowering, and record the same categories every week through the bloom.

Share the dates, photographs and findings with a local garden club, landcare group or the Australian Pollinator Census, then use the results to decide which plant deserves more space next season. A monitored planting provides more useful evidence for Australian gardeners than a label, one spectacular season or an untested assumption about pollinator preference.

In the Garden

Evaluator gardens are located across the Chicagoland area, representing a range of growing conditions. Visit our retail and wholesale partners to find trialled perennials for your own garden.

Retail & Wholesale: Hinsdale Nurseries (Willowbrook, IL), Mariani Nurseries (Kenosha, WI & Garden Prairie, IL), Northwind Perennials (Burlington, WI), The Growing Place (Aurora, IL).

Wholesale Only: Hinsdale Nurseries (Plano, IL), Intrinsic Perennial Gardens (Hebron, IL).

Our Evaluation Program

The 2017–2020 evaluation cycle included Agastache 'Blue Boa', Allium senescens 'Blue Eddy', Amsonia ciliata var. filifolia 'Georgia Pancake', Astilbe 'Chocolate Shogun', Boltonia astroides 'James Crocket', Brunnera 'Alexander's Great', and Geranium cinereum 'Jolly Jewel Purple'. Completed evaluations include Amsonia 'Blue Ice' (2004–07).

On April 10, 2020, the program published snapshot profiles for Vernonia lettermanii 'Iron Butterfly', Stokesia laevis 'Elf', Stachys officinalis 'Pink Cotton Candy', Lobelia 'Monet Moment', Helleborus 'Winter Thrillers', Geum 'Mai Tai', Geranium soboliferum 'Butterfly Kisses', Gentiana x intermedia 'True Blue', Eurybia divaricata, Asparagus 'Purple Passion', and Agastache 'Bolero'.

Browse the full collection of snapshots organized alphabetically — from A–D, E–H, I–Q, and R–Z — to find detailed performance data on perennials trialled across Chicagoland.

Close-up of drooping orange and yellow spurred flowers with slender petals
Cluster of light purple daisy-like flowers with yellow centers
Tall spike of orange-yellow tubular foxglove flowers against blurred green
Cluster of small tubular orange-red flowers among green leaves