Evaluating Perennials for Chicagoland Gardens
Perennials in Focus is a plant evaluation program that examines new and underused plants for Chicagoland, the third largest metropolitan area in the country. A group of horticultural experts trials and evaluates plants at numerous locations across the region. Results help consumers, public gardens, growers, landscape designers, breeders, and other industry professionals make informed plant choices.
Powdery mildew incidence in Phlox stolonifera and Phlox subulata
Powdery mildew can quickly change the appearance of a perennial planting, covering leaves with white patches that later turn grey or brown. Two related species often invite similar comparisons, yet they grow in distinctly different conditions. Phlox stolonifera forms spreading woodland colonies, while Phlox subulata creates low, dense mats suited to sunny borders and containers. Learn more about In The Garden.
Trial results must also match the climate where the plants will actually grow. The Perennials in Focus program tests plants across multiple Chicagoland gardens, recording flowering, dimensions and seasonal performance. Those Midwestern findings offer useful evidence, but Australian growers should interpret them alongside local heat, humidity, irrigation and winter conditions.
For this comparison, incidence means the proportion of leaves or plants showing symptoms, while severity describes how much of each affected leaf is covered. A plant can have low incidence but severe damage on a few leaves, so both measures should be considered. Daily watering habits, surrounding vegetation and the particular clone or cultivar can all alter the outcome.
| Characteristic | Phlox stolonifera | Phlox subulata |
|---|---|---|
| Growth habit | Upright, colony-forming perennial, generally 30–60 cm high | Low, mat-forming perennial, usually 10–15 cm high |
| Spreading method | Rhizomes and stolons can create broad patches | Compact trailing stems produce a ground-cover mound |
| Preferred exposure | Partial shade or dappled light | Full sun with good air movement |
| Moisture pattern | Prefers evenly moist, well-drained soil | Tolerates short dry periods once established; dislikes prolonged saturation |
| Typical flowering | Pink, white or purple flowers in late spring and early summer | Wide range of pink, purple and white flowers, mainly in spring |
| Likely mildew pattern | More visible where growth is crowded, shaded or stressed | Often less affected in open, sunny sites, although no cultivar is immune |
| Useful evaluation measures | Symptom frequency, coverage, plant vigour, spread and flowering period | Same measures, with particular attention to mat density and recovery |
Different growth habits create different risks
Phlox stolonifera is adapted to open woodland habitats, where plants receive filtered light and benefit from air moving through surrounding vegetation. Its taller stems and spreading habit can place leaves close to the soil and within dense patches. Under those conditions, a powdery mildew infection can progress through much of the colony without becoming conspicuous at first.
Phlox subulata comes from drier, rocky habitats and normally grows in full sun. Its low mat may still become dense enough to restrict airflow, especially when planted beside walls or beneath shrubs. Drought stress, excessive fertiliser and poor drainage can further weaken growth, although stress does not itself cause powdery mildew; it can make an existing infection more damaging.
The garden trial observations published through Perennials in Focus are valuable because they connect plant performance with actual garden conditions. For Australian readers, the most transferable information is the pattern of symptoms, not a simple declaration that one species is universally resistant. Local weather and maintenance determine whether that pattern develops each season.
Build an Australian field comparison
A sound trial uses several plants of each species at each site. Plants should receive similar soil, spacing and irrigation, while observers record the percentage of symptomatic leaves, the average severity score, flowering dates, height and spread. Assessment should continue across multiple seasons because an early outbreak following rain may not represent the plant’s long-term performance.
Melbourne’s cool, humid springs and sheltered gardens can create the sheltered, still conditions that favour mildew. Dense deciduous shrubs may provide useful shade during summer, yet their lower branches can also trap humidity around woodland phlox. Sydney presents a different pattern: warm, humid weather and summer rain can support vigorous growth, while coastal gardens may remain mild through winter. Trial sites in both cities should include sunny and partly shaded positions to separate species effects from location effects.
Perth’s dry summers provide a useful contrast, but irrigated gardens can still experience mildew when roots become stressed and plant growth is dense. Australian gardeners commonly water early in the morning, a helpful habit that limits prolonged leaf wetness, although it does not control powdery mildew by itself. Mulch, soil-level irrigation and regular inspections give observers consistent routines and reveal when symptoms first appear.
Several observers should score the same plants where possible. One person may notice the first white patch while another overlooks it, and ratings can drift as plants mature. Digital photographs taken from fixed points provide a simple audit trail, particularly when trials run through wet weather or a humid autumn.
Separate cultivar effects from species effects
The name on the nursery label may matter as much as the botanical name. Selections of Phlox stolonifera can differ in height, flower colour and vigour, while creeping phlox cultivars vary in density and resistance to stress. A disappointing trial may reflect one sensitive clone rather than the behaviour of the entire species.
Australia’s mix of independent nurseries, specialist perennial growers, garden centres and online marketplaces offers access to plants that are not always stocked locally. Buyers should check whether stock is accurately named and healthy, and whether a supplier makes evidence-based resistance claims. The Australian Consumer Law prohibits misleading representations, so wording such as “completely mildew-proof” should be treated cautiously unless the claim is properly substantiated.
Imported plant material also requires attention to biosecurity. Anyone considering bringing phlox from overseas should check the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry’s BICON system and comply with the Biosecurity Act 2015. Clean propagation material and documented nursery origin are preferable to unidentified plants carried informally across state borders.
Reduce mildew without losing flowering performance
Start with placement. Phlox subulata generally performs best in open sun, while Phlox stolonifera suits bright woodland conditions. Allow enough space for each plant’s expected spread, prune surrounding growth when circulation is poor and remove the weakest, mildew-prone stems. Dividing a crowded colony can improve airflow and renew vigorous growth without discarding the entire planting.
Watering habits are equally important. Direct irrigation toward the soil, apply mulch to reduce root stress and avoid compensating for dry soil with excessive watering. Remove fallen leaves and dispose of badly affected material through the local council’s green-waste guidance. Healthy, open growth is generally more valuable than attempting to preserve dense foliage that has already declined.
Where additional control is needed, only products registered in Australia should be considered. The APVMA evaluates agricultural chemicals, and the approved label is legally binding; it specifies crops, application rates, safety requirements and any restrictions near flowering plants or aquatic areas. Gardeners should never mix products outside the label directions, and they should protect themselves, children, pets and pollinators during and after application.
Make an evidence-based choice for your garden
When comparing trial records, look for repeated seasons and complete information rather than a single dramatic photograph. Consider whether flowering continued after infection, whether the planting recovered and how much space it occupied. A species with modest symptoms but poor recovery may be less useful than one that remains attractive while remaining contained.
Retail promotions can encourage buyers to search for a guaranteed “perfect” plant, just as risk-based entertainment can encourage unrealistic expectations. The principle of avoiding a sure-thing mindset is equally relevant when purchasing perennials and is reflected in guidance on responsible risk decisions. Trial evidence should inform a choice, not replace observation of the intended site.
Choose the phlox that matches the light, moisture and airflow you can provide, purchase healthy and accurately labelled stock, and record flowering and mildew symptoms through the growing season. Your own garden log will quickly reveal whether Phlox stolonifera, Phlox subulata or another perennial offers the more reliable long-term performance.
In the Garden
Evaluator gardens are located across the Chicagoland area, representing a range of growing conditions. Visit our retail and wholesale partners to find trialled perennials for your own garden.
Retail & Wholesale: Hinsdale Nurseries (Willowbrook, IL), Mariani Nurseries (Kenosha, WI & Garden Prairie, IL), Northwind Perennials (Burlington, WI), The Growing Place (Aurora, IL).
Wholesale Only: Hinsdale Nurseries (Plano, IL), Intrinsic Perennial Gardens (Hebron, IL).
Our Evaluation Program
The 2017–2020 evaluation cycle included Agastache 'Blue Boa', Allium senescens 'Blue Eddy', Amsonia ciliata var. filifolia 'Georgia Pancake', Astilbe 'Chocolate Shogun', Boltonia astroides 'James Crocket', Brunnera 'Alexander's Great', and Geranium cinereum 'Jolly Jewel Purple'. Completed evaluations include Amsonia 'Blue Ice' (2004–07).
On April 10, 2020, the program published snapshot profiles for Vernonia lettermanii 'Iron Butterfly', Stokesia laevis 'Elf', Stachys officinalis 'Pink Cotton Candy', Lobelia 'Monet Moment', Helleborus 'Winter Thrillers', Geum 'Mai Tai', Geranium soboliferum 'Butterfly Kisses', Gentiana x intermedia 'True Blue', Eurybia divaricata, Asparagus 'Purple Passion', and Agastache 'Bolero'.
Browse the full collection of snapshots organized alphabetically — from A–D, E–H, I–Q, and R–Z — to find detailed performance data on perennials trialled across Chicagoland.